Weeks later, they told us Livia had contacted them.

would assume the worst.

Another letter said Mitchell had begged her to call me.

He had told her I loved her.

But Livia wrote:

“That’s the problem. She loves me like a locked door.”

I kept reading.

Natalie had opened the door to Livia in the middle of the night and taken her in without blame, without judgment, without demanding answers.

I wanted to hate Natalie.

Instead, shame burned through me.

The sonogram was dated six weeks after prom.

The hospital bracelet showed that Livia’s baby, Rose, was already three